Not long after Esther arrives, she pushes a schoolmate off a slide, breaking her ankle. Max saw Esther shove the girl, but covers for Esther by saying that the girl "slipped". However, Kate grows suspicious when Esther, who watched Kate and John have sex, expresses far more knowledge of sex and its slang than would be expected for a child her age. She is further alarmed when Sister Abigail, the head of the orphanage, warns her and John about Esther's tendency to be around when things go wrong. Esther overhears this, and later kills Sister Abigail with a hammer to the head. She convinces Max to help her hide the body and the hammer. Daniel sees Esther and Max descending from his treehouse, where they hid that hammer, and later that night, Esther threatens to cut off his Daniel's penis if he tells anyone what he saw.Their chase takes them outside to a frozen pond, where Kate and Esther struggle before they falling through the broken ice. Kate crawls out of the hole, followed by Esther, who begs for her life, addressing Kate as her mother. Kate angrily responds that she is not her mother, and kicks Esther in the head, breaking her neck and sending her back into the pond to kill her self. "The orphan movie is a horror MOvie that Show Being an Orphan is not easy withing secrets in the dark side.."
